School Work
Do you remember American one-room country schools, or know
someone who does? I attended such a
school in central Wisconsin for grades K – 8 in the 1940s and early 50s. More than 50 years later, as a Peace Corps
volunteer currently teaching at a rural school in northeastern Thailand, I was
surprised to find several points of similarity – and also colossal differences,
of course – that prompted me to write this piece.
In my one-room school, students helped the teacher with the
work of keeping the school clean, orderly, and warm in the winter (coal stove
in the earlier years, later replaced by an “oil burner,” if memory serves). We all had “duties,” such as sweeping the
floors of the school building and outhouses (one for girls, one for boys),
bringing in water (the school had no running water), cleaning blackboards, clapping
erasers, and so on. Our school was very
small – sometimes there were fewer than ten students, other times twenty or so.
At my rural school in Thailand, one of the first things I
learned was how much “housekeeping” or janitorial work the students do. On the
first day of the term, first-period classes were not taught; instead, the
students went to their homerooms to be assigned duties. For example, in each homeroom,
a student is assigned to sweep the floor twice a day – the windows have grates
but no screens, so there are multiple entry points for dirt and also birds, who
tend to drop their, um, calling cards at random. Students also sweep the
walkways in front of buildings, empty trash bins, clean the toilets, deliver
the day’s free milk to homerooms, and bring fresh bottles of drinking water to
the teachers’ rooms. One thing they
don’t seem to do is clap the erasers – at least, the erasers in the rooms I
teach in are always saturated with chalk dust (yes, we use blackboards).
Student mopping in front of our building.
The village is small (pop. 3,000) but the school is
relatively large – it’s a comprehensive school (K-12), with about 630 students and
40 teachers. There is no administrative
staff except for the principal, vice-principal, ICT manager, and the
principal’s administrative assistant. One janitor is responsible for five
classroom buildings, an assembly hall, a small library, a store that sells
school supplies and snacks, and some storage sheds. There is no money to hire workers to do these
jobs, even though Thailand spends some 20% of its annual budget to provide free
education for students K-12, with attendance mandated through grade 9. Where
does the money go? Schools pay for the
students’ meals, textbooks and other learning resources (laboratory materials,
band instruments, etc.), recreational activities and uniforms. Each student has
several different uniforms that are worn on specific days, including a Scout
uniform, worn every Wednesday – all students are expected to join Scouts. Of course, teachers must be paid too, as well
as utility bills and related costs.
So, having janitorial and some administrative work done by
students rather than paid staff helps keep the school running – as in my
one-room school days, on a much smaller scale. Besides duties that must be done
every day, students do other tasks as needed. They pick up trash on the school
grounds, help move furniture, deliver textbooks to classrooms, deliver messages
from the principal’s office, help with set-up and tear-down for special events,
serve glasses of water to visitors before they ask, and more. Students even
sweep out the teachers’ room twice a day and wash the dishes that we leave
piled up from lunch and snacks.
This picture reminds me of what we called “Arbor Day” in my
one-room school, a day in the spring when we raked and cleaned up the entire
school yard.
When I started to do the dishes myself one day, other
teachers told me not to: “That’s the
students’ work.” As I thought about it,
I could see that if teachers started doing the work the students are expected
to do, it could begin to tear a hole in the fabric of the school culture.
The rural Thai school where I teach seems to have a sense of
camaraderie between teachers and students – I haven’t seen any students balk or
stall when reminded to do an assigned task. I believe this has much to do with the fact
that teachers and students share the work of keeping the school running. Students know that the work they do is valued
and needed; teachers appreciate the work the students do. In another post, I
will write about the many duties the teachers have besides teaching their
classes.
You wouldn't find a modern American student doing all that work at school without being paid. So you are saying Newt Gringrich was right? Students should be doing janitorial work at their school?
ReplyDeleteThank you Jeanette, for reminding us of how we evolved in American Education. The Education System in Thailand today is where you were when you were young. In fact, from where I stand, somewhat more equitable. I'm not sure Newt Gingrich meant for "all" students to do janitorial work in America. schools.
ReplyDeleteNewt Gingrich specifically said poor children. It wouldn't hurt the rich kids who have everything given to them to do janitorial work. They would learn what it meant to work for a dollar too.
ReplyDelete